Patient | Family | Country | Mutations in cDNA | Mutations in protein | Phenotype | SAdo [umol/l] in CSF *** | SAICAr [umol/l]in CSF | SAdo/ SAICAr in CSF | Ref. |
1 | 1 | Australia | -49T>C | severe | 4.9# | 6.9# | 0.7# | [21] | |
953C>T | P318L | ||||||||
2 | 2 | Italy | -49T>C | severe | 158 | 167 | 0.9 | [26] | |
1277G>A | R426H | ||||||||
3 | 3 | Norway | -49T>C | severe | [21] | ||||
1339T>C | S447P | ||||||||
4 | 4 | Germany | 421C>T | R141W | neonatal | 470## | 320## | 1.5## | [16] |
618C>A |
206-218del |
||||||||
5 | 5 | France | 1A>C | M1L | severe | 367 | 376 | 1.0 | [8] |
1120C>T | R374W | ||||||||
6 | 6 | United States | 1A>G | M1V | mild | 87* | 58* | 1.5* | [31] |
1342T>C | S448P | ||||||||
7 | 7 | Netherlands | 5C>T | A2V | neonatal | 1-2## | 1-2## | 1.0## | [34] |
S395R | |||||||||
8 | 8 | United Kingdom | 7G>C | A3P | neonatal | 477 | 921 | 0.5 | [22] |
578C>T | R190X | ||||||||
9 | 9 | Czech Republic | 8C>T | A3V | severe | 126 | 147 | 0.9 | [15] |
1009C>T | R337X | ||||||||
10 | 10 | Poland | 8C>T | A3V | severe | 338* | 323* | 1.0* | [33] |
lack of mRNA | |||||||||
11 | 11 | Poland | 69C>G | S23R | severe | 311 | 374 | 0.8 | [14] |
1277G>A | R426H | ||||||||
12 | 12 | Germany | 76A>T | M26L | severe | 370* | 400* | 0.9* | [16] |
1277G>A | R426H | ||||||||
13 | 13 | Belgium | 214A>G | I72V | severe | n.d. | n.d. | [20] | |
736A>G | K246E | ||||||||
14 | 14 | Australia | 240A>C | E80D | mild | 1.89# | 0.87# | 2.4# | [30] |
261T>G | D87E | ||||||||
15 | 15 | Italy | 298C>G | P100A | severe | 75* | 60* | 1.3* | [36] |
1264G>T | D422Y | ||||||||
16 | 16 | Czech Republic | 340T>C | Y114H | mild | 283 | 127 | 2.2 | [15] |
569G>A | R190Q | ||||||||
17 | 16 | Czech Republic | 340T>C | Y114H | mild | 260 | 125 | 2.1 | [15] |
569G>A | R190Q | ||||||||
18 | 17 | Poland | 340T>C | Y114H | neonatal | n.d. | n.d. | [14] | |
725C>T | T242I | ||||||||
19 | 17 | Poland | 340T>C | Y114H | severe | 562 | 599 | 0.9 | [14] |
725C>T | T242I | ||||||||
20 | 18 | Czech Republic | 340T>C | Y114H | neonatal | 684 | 1100 | 0.6 | [25] |
1128G>C | E376D | ||||||||
21 | 19 | Czech Republic | 340T>C | Y114H | severe | 649 | 953 | 0.7 | [31] |
1187G>A | R396H | ||||||||
22 | 20 | Germany | 340T>C | Y114H | neonatal | 1.1* | [25] | ||
1277G>A | R426H | ||||||||
23 | 20 | Germany | 340T>C | Y114H | neonatal | n.d. | n.d. | [25] | |
1277G>A | R426H | ||||||||
24 | 20 | Germany | 340T>C | Y114H | neonatal | n.d. | n.d. | [25] | |
1277G>A | R426H | ||||||||
25 | 21 | Czech Republic | 340T>C | Y114H | neonatal | 169 | 330 | 0.5 | [25] |
1277G>A | R426H | ||||||||
26 | 22 | Czech Republic | 340T>C | Y114H | neonatal | 1.1* | [33] | ||
1277G>A | R426H | ||||||||
27 | 23 | Malaysia | 445C>G | R194G | severe | 380* | 370* | 1.0* | [10] |
774_778insG | A260GfsX24 | ||||||||
28 | 24 | Belgium | 569G>A | R190Q | moderate | 379 | 214 | 1.8 | [11] |
736A>G | K246E | ||||||||
29 | 25 | Czech Republic | 580C>T | R194C | severe | 269 | 281 | 1.0 | [15] |
802G>A |
D268N | ||||||||
30 | 26 | Germany | 580C>T | R194C | neonatal | n.d. | n.d. | [25] | |
1186C>T |
R396C | ||||||||
31 | 27 | Poland | 643G>C | D215H | severe | 290* | 215* | 1.3* | [14] |
1052T>C |
I351T | ||||||||
32 | 28 | Morocco | 674T>C | M225T | severe | 101* | 63* | 1.6* | [6] |
674T>C |
M225T | ||||||||
33 | 28 | Morocco | 674T>C | M225T | severe | 79* | 49* | 1.6* | [6] |
674T>C |
M225T | ||||||||
34 | 29 | Poland | 802G>C | D268H | mild | 1816* | 896* | 2.0* | [14] |
1277G>A |
R426H | ||||||||
35 | 30 | United States | 802G>A | D268N | severe | n.d. | n.d. | [31] | |
1400C>G |
P467R | ||||||||
36 | 31 | Netherlands | N297S | mild to severe | 370 | 210 | 1.8 | [7] | |
907C>T |
R303C | ||||||||
37 | 32 | Netherlands | N297S | mild | 1130 | 390 | 2.9 | [7] | |
907C>T |
R303C | ||||||||
38 | 33 | Netherlands | 907C>T | R303C | mild | 4.0 | [12] | ||
907C>T |
R303C | ||||||||
39 | 34 | ? | 907C>T | R303C | mild | 3.0 | [28] | ||
907C>T | R303C | ||||||||
40 | 35 | Spain | 931C>G | L311V | severe | 273 | 180 | 1.5 | [2] |
1187G>A | R396H | ||||||||
41 | 36 | Spain | 1090G>A | V364M | severe | 5.0** | 2.8** | 1.8** | [2] |
1355G>C | R452P | ||||||||
42 | 36 | Spain | 1090G>A | V364M | severe | 359 | 228 | 1.6 | [2] |
1355G>C | R452P | ||||||||
43 | 37 | Spain | 1107A>C | I369L | severe | 1.9* | [29] | ||
1107A>C | I369L | ||||||||
44 | 38 | ? | 1267C>G | L423V | moderate | n.d. | n.d. | [9] | |
1277G>A | R426H | ||||||||
45 | 39 | Germany | 1277G>A | R426H | severe | n.d. | n.d. | [31] | |
1277G>A | R426H | ||||||||
46 | 40 | Belgium | 1277G>A | R426H | severe | 1.3 | [12] | ||
1277G>A | R426H | ||||||||
47 | 41 | Poland | 1277G>A | R426H | moderate | 198* | 133* | 1.5* | [14] |
1277G>A | R426H | ||||||||
48 | 42 | Poland | 1277G>A | R426H | moderate | 210* | 125* | 1.7* | [14] |
1277G>A | R426H | ||||||||
49 | 43 | Netherlands | 1277G>A | R426H | severe | 218 | 213 | 1.0 | [9] |
1277G>A | R426H | ||||||||
50 | 44 | Netherlands | 1277G>A | R426H | severe | [9] | |||
1277G>A | R426H | ||||||||
51 | 45 | Netherlands | 1277G>A | R426H | severe | [9] | |||
1277G>A | R426H | ||||||||
52 | 46 | Portugal | 1277G>A | R426H | severe | 271 | 173 | 1.6 | [4] |
1277G>A | R426H | ||||||||
53 | 46 | Portugal | 1277G>A | R426H | severe | 178 | 132 | 1.4 | [4] |
1277G>A | R426H | ||||||||
54 | 47 | Netherlands | 1277G>A | R426H | severe | 1.2 | [28] | ||
1277G>A | R426H | ||||||||
55 | 48 | Czech Republic | 1277G>A | R426H | severe | 1.2* | [15] | ||
1277G>A | R426H | ||||||||
56 | 49 | Turkey | 1277G>A | R426H | severe | [9] | |||
1277G>A | R426H | ||||||||
57 | 50 | Portugal | 1277G>A | R426H | severe | 242 | 197 | 1.2 | [4] |
1277G>A | R426H | ||||||||
58 | 51 | Netherlands | 1277G>A | R426H | severe | 1.5 | [28] | ||
1277G>A | R426H | ||||||||
59 | 52 | Germany | 1277G>A | R426H | severe | 292 | 207 | 1.4 | [7] |
1277G>A | R426H | ||||||||
60 | 53 | United States | 1277G>A | R426H | mild | 2.6* | [15] | ||
1288G>A | D430N | ||||||||
61 | 54 | Netherlands | 1277G>A | R426H | moderate | 2.5 | [28] | ||
1349C>G | T450S | ||||||||
62 | 54 | Netherlands | 1277G>A | R426H | moderate | [9] | |||
1349C>G | T450S | ||||||||
63 | 55 | Morocco | 1312T>C | S438P | severe | 162 | 111 | 1.5 | [32] |
1312T>C | S438P | ||||||||
64 | 55 | Morocco | 1312T>C | S438P | severe | 166 | 154 | 1.1 | [32] |
1312T>C | S438P | ||||||||
65 | 56 | Colombia | nd | nd | neonatal | 160 | 164 | 1.0 | [2] |
nd | nd | ||||||||
66 | 56 | Colombia | nd | nd | neonatal | n.d. | n.d. | [2] | |
nd | nd | ||||||||
67 | 57 | United States | 1277G>A | R426H | mild to severe | 222 | n.d. | [33] | |
1277G>A | R426H | ||||||||
68 | 57 | United States | nd | nd | mild to severe | 430 | n.d. | [33] | |
nd | nd | ||||||||
69 | 58 | United Kingdom | -49T>C | severe | 0.4## | 0.4## | 1.0## | [17] | |
1277G>A | R426H | ||||||||
70 | 59 | United Kingdom | 421C>T | R141W | severe | 2.0## | 1.3## | 1.6## | [17] |
1304C>T | P435L | ||||||||
71 | 60 | Germany | 731C>T | T244I | moderate | 440* | n.d.* | [33] | |
1191+5G>C | splice | ||||||||
72 | 61 | Dominican Republic | 1107A>C | I369L | severe | 1.9* | [27] | ||
1107A>C | I369L | ||||||||
73 | 62 | Spain | 1165A>G | M389V | mild | 3.4* | [27] | ||
1165A>G | M389V | ||||||||
74 | 63 | Spain | 1165A>G | M389V | mild to severe | 2.7* | [27] | ||
1165A>G | M389V | ||||||||
75 | 64 | Ireland | 340T>C | Y114H | severe | 0.3## | 0.2## | 1.7## | |
no RNA | prob.splice | ||||||||
76 | 65 | France | 340T>C | Y114H | mild | [23] | |||
1253G>C | G418A | ||||||||
77 | 65 | France | 340T>C | Y114H | mild | 322* | 241* | 1.3* | [23] |
1253G>C | G418A | ||||||||
78 | 65 | France | 340T>C | Y114H | severe | [23] | |||
1253G>C | G418A | ||||||||
79 | 66 | Australia | -49T>C | severe | 421* | 324* | 1.3* | [35] | |
889_891 dupAAT |
|||||||||
80 | 67 | Poland | 1277G>A | R426H | mild | 332* | 161* | [13] | |
802G>C | D268H | ||||||||
81 | 68 | ? | 736 A>G | K246E | severe | 120 | 117 | 1.0 | [37] |
nd | nd | ||||||||
82 | 69 | ? | IVS12+1/G>C | splice site exon 12 | severe | 305 | 436 | 0.7 | [37] |
802G>A | D268N | ||||||||
83 | 70 | ? | 736A>G | K246Q | severe | 282* | [3] | ||
947T>C | M316Y | ||||||||
84 | 71 | ? | 1277G>A | R426H | severe | [3] | |||
1277G>A | R426H | ||||||||
85 | 72 | ? | 1277G>A | R426H | severe | 124* | [3] | ||
1277G>A | R426H | ||||||||
86 | 72 | ? | 1277G>A | R426H | severe | 97* | [3] | ||
1277G>A | R426H | ||||||||
87 | 73 | China | 71C>T | P24L | severe | [19] | |||
1387-1389delGAG | E463- | ||||||||
88 | 73 | China | 71C>T | P24L | severe | [19] | |||
1387-1389delGAG | E463- | ||||||||
89 | 74 | China | 71C>T | P24L | severe | [19] | |||
134G>A | W45* | ||||||||
90 | 74 | China | 71C>T | P24L | severe | [19] | |||
134G>A | W45* | ||||||||
91 | 75 | ? | 926G>A | R309H | mild | 116* | 58* | 2.0* | [18] |
1191+5G>C | splice site | ||||||||
92 | 76 | Italy | 340T>C | Y114H | severe | 236* | 38* | 6.2* | [23] |
65C>T | A22V | ||||||||
93 | 77 | Germany | 76A>T | M26L | mild | 22* | 6* | 3.6* | [18] |
1187G>A | R396H | ||||||||
94 | 77 | Germany | 76A>T | M26L | mild | 20* | 5* | 3.7* | [18] |
1187G>A | R396H | ||||||||
95 | 78 | Israel (Arab) | 1027G>A | Q343K | moderate | 122## | [24] | ||
1027G>A | Q343K | ||||||||
96 | 79 | Turkey | 1277G>A | R426H | moderate | [5] | |||
910T>G | C304G | ||||||||
97 | 80 | Qatar | 1343_1345 delCTT |
S448del | neonatal | 208* | 223* | 0.9* | [23] |
502G>A | V168I | ||||||||
98 | 81 | ? | 1277G>A | R426H | severe | 457 | [23] | ||
1277G>A | R426H | ||||||||
99 | 82 | ? | 1277G>A | R426H | severe | 856 | [23] | ||
1277G>A | R426H | ||||||||
100 | 83 | ? | 1277G>A | R426H | severe | 674 | [23] | ||
1277G>A | R426H | ||||||||
101 | 84 | ? | R149G | severe | positive | [23] | |||
W175C | |||||||||
102 | 85 | ? | 421C>T | R141W | severe | 1.4* | [23] | ||
P318L | |||||||||
103 | 86 | ? | 1277G>A | R426H | severe | 311 | 374 | 0.8 | [23] |
S23R | |||||||||
104 | 87 | ? | 1277G>A | R426H | moderate | [23] | |||
1277G>A | R426H | ||||||||
105 | 87 | ? | 1277G>A | R426H | ? | [23] | |||
1277G>A | R426H | ||||||||
106 | 88 | ? | E343K | mild | 123* | [23] | |||
E343K | |||||||||
107 | 89 | ? | 1277G>A | R426H | mild | 469* | [23] | ||
D430D | |||||||||
108 | 90 | ? | T450S | mild | 176* | 73* | 2.4* | [23] | |
D332H | |||||||||
109 | 91 | ? | 701+1G>G/A | intron 6 | severe | positive MR spect | positive MR spect | [1] | |
926G>G/A | intron 9 |
normal range SAICAr: undetectable; SAdo: 0.6-7.4 mmol/mol creatinine (in urine) [38]
# umol/mg of creatinine (in urine)## mmol/l (in urine) * mmol/mol of creatinine (in urine)** umol/l (in plasma)*** CSF = cerebrospinal fluid
References:
[1] Banerjee, A., Bhatia, V., Didwal, G. et al. ADSL Deficiency – The Lesser-Known Metabolic Epilepsy in Infancy. Indian J Pediatr 88, 263–265 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12098-020-03435-4 |
[2] Castro, M., C. Perez-Cerda, et al. (2002). Neuropediatrics 33(4): 186-9. |
[3] Donti TR, Cappuccio G, Hubert L, et al. Diagnosis of adenylosuccinate lyase deficiency by metabolomic profiling in plasma reveals a phenotypic spectrum. Mol Genet Metab Rep. 2016;8:61-66. Published 2016 Jul 27. doi:10.1016/j.ymgmr.2016.07.007 |
[4] Edery, P., S. Chabrier, et al. (2003). Am J Med Genet A 120(2): 185-90. |
[5] Fatma Cakmak Celik, Mehmet Mustafa Ozlu, Serdar Ceylaner, A newborn case of adenylosuccinate lyase deficiency with a novel heterozygous mutation diagnosed by whole exome sequencing, Clinical Neurology and Neurosurgery, Vol 202, 2021, 106506,ISSN 03 |
[6] Gitiaux, C., I. Ceballos-Picot, et al. (2009). Eur J Hum Genet 17(1): 133-6. |
[7] Henneke M, Dreha-Kulaczewski S, Brockmann K, van der Graaf M, Willemsen MA, Engelke U, Dechent P, Heerschap A, Helms G, Wevers RA, Gartner J. (2010) In vivo proton MR spectroscopy findings specific for adenylosuccinate lyase deficiency. NMR Biomed. |
[8] Holder-Espinasse, M., S. Marie, et al. (2002). J Med Genet 39(6): 440-2. |
[9] http://www.icp.ucl.ac.be/adsldb |
[10] Chen BC, McGown IN, Thong MK, Pitt J, Yunus ZM, Khoo TB, Ngu LH, Duley JA. (2010) Adenylosuccinate lyase deficiency in a Malaysian patient, with novel adenylosuccinate lyase gene mutations. J Inherit Metab Dis. DOI:10.1007/s10545-010-9056-z |
[11] Jaeken J, Van den Bergh F, et al. (1992). J Inherit Metab Dis 15(3):416-8. |
[12] Jaeken J, Wadman SK, van den et al. (1988). Eur J Pediatr 148(2):126-31. |
[13] Jurecka A, Zikanova M, Jurkiewicz E, Tylki-Szymańska A. Attenuated adenylosuccinate lyase deficiency: a report of one case and a review of the literature. Neuropediatrics. 2014 Feb;45(1):50-5. doi: 10.1055/s-0033-1337335. Epub 2013 Mar 16. PMID: 23504561 |
[14] Jurecka, A., M. Zikanova, et al. (2008). Mol Genet Metab 94(4): 435-42. |
[15] Kmoch, S., H. Hartmannova, et al. (2000). Hum Mol Genet 9(10): 1501-13. |
[16] Kohler M, Assmann B, et al. (1999). Eur J Paediatr Neurol 3(1):3-6. |
[17] Lundy CT, Jungbluth H, Pohl KR, Siddiqui A, Marinaki AM, Mundy H, Champion MP. (2010) Adenylosuccinate lyase deficiency in the United Kingdom pediatric population: first three cases. Pediatr Neurol 43(5):351-4. |
[18] Macchiaiolo M, Barresi S, Cecconi F, et al. A mild form of adenylosuccinate lyase deficiency in absence of typical brain MRI features diagnosed by whole exome sequencing. Ital J Pediatr. 2017;43(1):65. Published 2017 Aug 2. doi:10.1186/s13052-017-0383-7 |
[19] Mao X, Li K, Tang B, et al. Novel mutations in ADSL for Adenylosuccinate Lyase Deficiency identified by the combination of Trio-WES and constantly updated guidelines. Sci Rep. 2017;7(1):1625. Published 2017 May 9. doi:10.1038/s41598-017-01637-z |
[20] Marie, S., H. Cuppens, et al. (1999). Hum Mutat 13(3): 197-202. |
[21] Marie, S., V. Race, et al. (2002). Am J Hum Genet 71(1): 14-21. |
[22] Marinaki, A. M., M. Champion, et al. (2004). Nucleosides Nucleotides Nucleic Acids 23(8-9): 1231-3. |
[23] Mastrogiorgio G, Macchiaiolo M, Buonuomo PS, et al. Clinical and molecular characterization of patients with adenylosuccinate lyase deficiency. Orphanet J Rare Dis. 2021;16(1):112. Published 2021 Mar 1. doi:10.1186/s13023-021-01731-6 |
[24] Michal M. Andelman-Gur, Hirotomo Saitsu, et al. (2020). Myoclonic tremor status as a presenting symptom of adenylosuccinate lyase deficiency. Eur J Med Genet 63(12). doi: 10.1016/j.ejmg.2020.104061 |
[25] Mouchegh, K., Zikanova, M. (2007). J Pediatr 150(1): 57-61 e2. |
[26] Nassogne M, Henrot B, et al. (2000). Brain Dev 22(6):383-6. |
[27] Perez-Duenas B, Sempere A, Campistol J, Alonso-Colmenero I, Diez M, Gonzalez V, Merinero B, Desviat LR, Artuch R. 2012. Novel features in the evolution of adenylosuccinate lyase deficiency. Eur J Paediatr Neurol 16(4):343-8. |
[28] Race, V., S. Marie, et al. (2000). Hum Mol Genet 9(14): 2159-65. |
[29] Sempere, A., et al., (2010) J Inherit Metab Dis; Study of inborn errors of metabolism in urine from patients with unexplained mental retardation. |
[30] Sivendran, S., D. Patterson, et al. (2004). J Biol Chem 279(51): 53789-97. |
[31] Spiegel, E. K., R. F. Colman, et al. (2006). Mol Genet Metab 89(1-2): 19-31. |
[32] Stone, R. L., J. Aimi, et al. (1992). Nat Genet 1(1): 59-63. |
[33] unpublished |
[34] van den Bergh, F. A., A. N. Bosschaart, et al. (1998). Neuropediatrics 29(1): 51-3. |
[35] van Werkhoven MA, Duley JA, McGown I, Munce T, Freeman JL, Pitt JJ: Dev Med Child Neurol 2013, 55:1060-1064. |
[36] Verginelli, D., B. Luckow, et al. (1998). Biochim Biophys Acta 1406(1): 81-4. |
[37] Zulfiqar M, Lin DD, Van der Graaf M, et al. Novel proton MR spectroscopy findings in adenylosuccinate lyase deficiency. J Magn Reson Imaging. 2013;37(4):974-980. doi:10.1002/jmri.23852[38] Blau N, Duran KM, Gibson M.Laboratory Guide to the Methods in Biochemical Genetics. Springer 2008. doi:10.1007/978-3-540-76698-8 |